Peer Review Process
Peer Review Process
J-MECT maintains a rigorous standard for the publication of scholarly articles. To ensure the quality, originality, and scientific significance of published research, every submitted manuscript undergoes a systematic and objective peer review process.
1. Initial Editorial Review (Desk Review)
Upon submission, the Chief Editor and/or Managing Editor will conduct an initial screening of the manuscript. This step evaluates:
-
Aims and Scope: Whether the manuscript falls within the focus and scope of J-MECT.
-
Originality: The manuscript is checked for plagiarism using similarity detection software (e.g., Turnitin or iThenticate). Manuscripts with an unacceptable level of similarity will be rejected immediately.
-
Format and Guidelines: Compliance with the journal’s author guidelines, formatting, and structural requirements.
Manuscripts that do not meet these fundamental criteria may be rejected at this stage (Desk Rejection) without being sent for peer review.
2. Double-Blind Peer Review
If the manuscript passes the initial screening, it proceeds to the formal peer review phase. J-MECT employs a Double-Blind Peer Review process.
-
Anonymity: Both the reviewers' and the authors' identities are concealed from each other throughout the review process. Authors must ensure their names and affiliations are removed from the main manuscript file.
-
Reviewer Selection: The manuscript will be sent to at least two (2) independent reviewers who are recognized experts in the specific subject area of the manuscript.
3. Reviewer Evaluation Criteria
Reviewers will evaluate the manuscript based on several critical factors, including but not limited to:
-
Originality and novelty of the research.
-
Theoretical foundation and relevance to current literature.
-
Appropriateness and rigor of the research methodology.
-
Clarity, depth, and validity of the results and discussion.
-
Contribution to the field of education, mathematics, computing, or technology.
-
Clarity of writing and overall organization of the manuscript.
4. Editorial Decision
Based on the detailed feedback and recommendations from the peer reviewers, the Section Editor and Chief Editor will make the final decision. The possible decisions are:
-
Accept Submission: The manuscript is accepted for publication without any further changes.
-
Revisions Required (Minor Revisions): The manuscript requires slight adjustments (e.g., formatting, typographical errors, minor clarifications) based on reviewer feedback.
-
Resubmit for Review (Major Revisions): The manuscript requires significant changes (e.g., re-analysis of data, expanding literature, rewriting sections) and will undergo a second round of review after resubmission.
-
Decline Submission: The manuscript is rejected as it lacks originality, has fundamental methodological flaws, or does not meet the journal's standards.
5. Revision Process
If revisions are required, authors are expected to submit the revised manuscript along with a "Response to Reviewers" document detailing how each comment was addressed, within the timeframe specified by the Editor.
6. Final Decision and Production
The ultimate responsibility for the acceptance or rejection of a manuscript rests with the Editor-in-Chief. Once accepted, the manuscript will proceed to the copyediting, layout formatting, and proofreading stages before final publication.







